Low bone mineral density (BMD) has long been recognized as an important predictor of fracture risk. Diagnostic criteria for osteoporosis were initially based on how many standard deviations a patient's BMD drops from the mean BMD of a female reference group, specifically young (aged 20-29 years) white women (CDC, 2002). The T-score is the standard deviation from the mean for this reference group. Negative T-scores indicate bone loss. Based on studies of women, a T-score of -2.5 (i.e., 2.5 S.D. below the mean for the reference group) has been defined as the diagnostic cutoff for osteoporosis (World Health Organization, 2003).
Between 1988 and 1994, the U.S. CDC collected BMD data from more than 14,000 U.S. women and men (National Center for Health Statistics, 1994). In 1997, a reference population of young men was used to calculate T-scores for male patients on the basis of healthy male (rather than healthy female) BMD values (Looker, 1997).
Calculating men's T-scores based on a male reference population greatly alters diagnosis rates. The prevalence of osteoporosis in men was estimated as 1%-4% using a female reference population; it has been estimated to be 3%-6% using a male reference population
(Looker, 1997; Cummings, 2002). This practice marks an important gendered innovation (see Method).
The T ≤ -2.5 cutoff (using a male reference population) is a common diagnostic for osteoporosis in men, although this is a matter of debate (Szulc et al., 2012). In a recent study of more than 7,000 men and women age 55 and older, 56% of non-vertebral fractures in women and 79% of non-vertebral fractures in men occurred in participants who were not diagnosed with osteoporosis according to the T ≤ -2.5 cutoff (Schuit et al., 2004). Moreover, there are concerns about the usefulness of T-scores in predicting fracture risk, especially in premenopausal women and men under age 50 (Leslie et al., 2006; Cummings, 2006).
Multiple international models for diagnosing osteoporosis have been established. The Canadian Medical Association, the United Kingdom's National Osteoporosis Guideline Group (NOGG) and Royal College of Physicians, and the German Dachverband Osteologie e.V. (DVO) each endorse different protocols for osteoporosis diagnosis (Papaioannou et al., 2010; Compston et al., 2008; Baum et al., 2008).
Developing a male reference population represented a gendered innovation that led, in turn, to further clinical research—see Designing Health & Biomedical Research. These include:
Researchers studying differences both between and within groups of women and men have identified secondary contributors to osteoporosis and metabolic bone disorders (SECOBs), medical conditions, and treatments that increase the risk of osteoporotic fracture. Understanding SECOBs is especially important in estimating men's fracture risk; men with fragility fractures are more likely than women to have previously diagnosed SECOBs, and when patients are screened after a fracture, new SECOBs are more often found in men (50%) than in women (32%) (Ryan et al., 2011; Tannenbaum et al., 2002). New diagnostics include the following:
In addition to the above, other systems of fracture risk estimation exist; Gimeno et al. describe nine different systems as "most commonly used" (2010).
Clinicians continue to debate the relative advantages and disadvantages of the FRAX, GFRC, and QFracture systems, all of which can be used to estimate a patient's risk of osteoporotic fracture over the next ten years (Bolland et al., 2011; Bennett et al., 2010).
Osteoporosis has been reconceptualized as affecting both women and men. This gendered innovation led to the development of male reference populations, allowing for better evaluation of fracture risk in men. BMD alone, however, is not a good predictor of fracture in women or men. New diagnostics, such as FRAX, GFRC, and QFracture, may predict a patient's fracture risk more accurately than BMD alone by analyzing factors intersecting with sex and gender.
Ahmed, A.I.H., Blake, G.M., Rymer, J.M., & Fogelman, I. (1997). Screening for Osteopenia and Osteoporosis: Do the Accepted Normal Ranges Lead to Overdiagnosis? Osteoporosis International, 7, 432-438.
Aloia, J.F. (2003). African Americans, 25-hydroxyvitamin D, and osteoporosis: a paradox. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 88 (supplement), 545S-50S.
Amin, S. (2010). Epidemiology of Fractures. In Orwoll, E., Bilezikian, J., & Vanderschueren, D. (Eds.), Osteoporosis in Men: The Effects of Gender on Skeletal Health, Second Edition, pp. 351-361. London: Elsevier.
Amin, S., Zhang, Y., Felson, D.T., Sawin, C.T., Hannan, M.T., Wilson, P.W., & Kiel, D.P. (2006). Estradiol, Testosterone, and the Risk for Hip Fractures in Elderly Men from the Framingham Study. American Journal of Medicine, 119, 426-433.
Baron, J.A., Barrett, J., Malenka, D., Fisher, E., Kniffin, W., Bubolz, T., & Tosteson, R. (1994). Racial Differences in Fracture Risk. Epidemiology, 1 (5), 42-47.
Bennett, B. (2004). Osteoporosis in Men. The NIH Word on Health: Consumer Health Information Based on Research from the National Institutes of Health, April.
Bennett, A., Adlan, A., & Johansen, A. (2010). FRAX and QFracture—Which is the Better Screening Tool for Hip Fracture Risk? Osteoporosis International: Abstracts of the Osteoporosis Conference 2010, 21 (3), S447.
Binkley, N., & Alder, R. (2010). Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry (DXA) in Men. In Orwoll, E., Bilezikian, J., & Vanderschueren, D. (Eds.), Osteoporosis in Men: The Effects of Gender on Skeletal Health, Second Edition, pp. 525-541. London: Elsevier.
Binkley, N.C., Schmeer, P., Wasnich, R.D., & Lenchik, L. (2002). What Are the Criteria by Which a Densitometric Diagnosis of Osteoporosis Can Be Made in Males and Non-Caucasians? Journal of Clinical Densitometry, 3 (5), s19-s27.
Burge, R., Dawson-Hughes, B., Solomon, D., Wong, J., King, A., & Tosteson, A., (2007). Incidence and Economic Burden of Osteoporosis-Related Fractures in the United States, 2005-2025. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 22 (3), 465-475.
Campion, J.M., & Maricic, M.J. (2003). Osteoporosis in Men. American Family Physician, 7 (67), 1521-1526.
Castro, J.P., Joseph, L.A., Shin, J.J., Arora, S.K., Nicasio, J., Shatzkes, J., Raklyar, I., Erlikh, E., Pantone, V., Bahtiyar, G., Chandler, L., Pabon, L., Choudhry, S., Ghadiri, N., Pramodini, G., Muniyappa, R., von-Gicyzki, H., & McFarlane, S.I. (2005). Differential Effect of Obesity on Bone Mineral Density in White, Hispanic and African American Women: A Cross Sectional Study. Nutrition and Metabolism, 9 (2), 1-7.
Cauley, J., Fullman, R.L., Stone, K.L., Zmuda, J.M., Bauer, D.C., Barrett-Connor, E., Ensrud, K., Lau, E., & Orwoll, E.S. (2005). Factors Associated with the Lumbar Spine and Proximal Femur Bone Mineral Density in Older Men. For the Mr. OS Research Group. Osteoporosis International, 16, 1525-1537.
Cauley, J.A., Zmuda, J.M., Wisniewski, S.R., Krishnaswami, S., Palermo, L., Stone, K.L., Black, D.M., & Nevitt, M.C. (2004). Bone Mineral Density and Prevalent Vertebral Fractures in Men and Women. Osteoporosis International, 15, 32-37.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2002). National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES): Osteoporosis. Washington, D.C.: United States Department of Health and Human Services National Center for Health Statistics.
Cummings, S.R., Bates, D., & Black, D.M. (2002). Clinical Use of Bone Densitometry: Scientific Review. Journal of the American Medical Association, 16 (288), 1889-1897.
Cummings, S.R., Cawthon, P.M., Ensrud, K.E., Cauley, J.A., Fink, H.A., & Orwoll, E.S. for the Osteoporotic Fractures in Men (MrOS) and Study of Osteoporotic Fractures (SOF) Research Groups. (2006). BMD and Risk of Hip and Nonvertebral Fractures in Older Men: A Prospective Study and Comparison With Older Women. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 10 (21), 1550-1556.
Cummings, S.R., Cauley, J.A., Palermo, L., Ross, P.D., Wasnich, R.D., Black, D., & Falkner, K.G. for the Study of Osteoporotic Fractures Research Group. (1994). Racial Differences in Hip Axis Lengths Might Explain Racial Differences in Rates of Hip Fracture. Osteoporosis International, 4, 226-229.
Durie, B., Katz, M., Crowley, J. (2005). Osteonecrosis of the Jaw and Bisphosphonates. New England Journal Of Medicine, 353, 99-102.
Duster, T. (2009). Debating Reality and Relevance. Science, 324 (5931), 1144-1145.
Ebeling, P.R. (2008). Osteoporosis in Men. The New England Journal of Medicine, 358, 1474-1482.
Farmer, M.E., White, L.R., Brody, J.A., & Bailey, K.R. (1984). Race and Sex Differences in Hip Fracture Incidence. American Journal of Public Health, 12 (74), 1374-1380.
Faulkner, K. & Orwoll, E. (2002). Implications in the Use of T-Scores for the Diagnosis of Osteoporosis in Men. Journal of Clinical Densitometry, 1 (5), 87-93.
Fausto-Sterling, A. (2008). The Bare Bones of Race. Social Studies of Science, 38, 657-694.
Fausto-Sterling, A. (2005). The Bare Bones of Sex: Part 1 – Sex and Gender. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 2 (30), 1491-1527.
Finkelstein, J.S. Brockwell, S.E., Mehta, V., Greendale, G.A., Sowers, M.F.R., Ettinger, B., Lo, J.C., Johnston, J.M., Cauley, J.A., Danielson, M.E., & Neer, R.M. (2008). Bone Mineral Density Changes During the Menopause Transition in a Multiethnic Cohort of Women. The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 93, 861-868.
Fleming, R. (1999). New NIAMS Grant Targets Osteoporosis in Men. National Institutes of Health.
Francis, M.D., & Valent, D.J. (2007). Historical Perspectives on the Clinical Development of Bisphosphonates in the Treatment of Bone Diseases. Journal of Musculoskeletal and Neuronal Interactions, 1 (7), 2-8.
Geusens, P., & Dinant, G. (2007). Integrating a Gender Dimension into Osteoporosis and Fracture Risk Research. Gender Medicine, 4 (S2), S147-S161.
Giusti, A., & Papapoulos, S. (2010). Treatment of Male Osteoporosis with Bisphosphonates. In Orwoll, E., Bilezikian, J., & Vanderschueren, D. (Eds.), Osteoporosis in Men: The Effects of Gender on Skeletal Health, Second Edition, pp. 667-681. London: Elsevier.
Griffin, M.R., Ray, W.A., Fought, R.L., & Melton III, L.J. (1992). Black-White Differences in Fracture Rates. American Journal of Epidemiology, 11 (36), 1378-1385.
Gürlek, A., Bayraktar, M., & Ariyürek, M. (2000). Inappropriate Reference Range for Peak Bone Mineral Density in Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry: Implications for the Interpretation of T-scores. Osteoporosis International, 11, 809-813.
Høiberg, M., Nielsen, T.L., Wraae, K., Abrahamsen, B., Hagen, C., Andersen, M., & Brixen, K. (2007). Population-Based Reference Values for Bone Mineral Density in Young Men. Osteoporosis International, 18, 1507-1514.
Jackson, K.A., & Savaiano, D.A., (2001). Lactose Maldigestion, Calcium Intake and Osteoporosis in African-, Asian-, and Hispanic-Americans. Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 2 (20), 198S-207S.
Jacobsen, S.J., Goldberg, J., Miles, T.P., Brody, J.A., Stiers, W., & Rimm, A.A. (1990). Regional Variation in the Incidence of Hip Fracture. Journal of the American Medical Association, 4 (264), 500-502.
Kanis, J., Burlet, N., Cooper, C., Delmas, P., Reginster, J., Borgstrom, F., & Rizzoli, R. (2008a) European Guidance for the Diagnosis and Management of Osteoporosis in Postmenopausal Women. Osteoporosis International, 19 (4), 399-428.
Kanis, J., Johnell, O., Oden, A., & McCloskey, E. (2008b). FRAX and the Assessment of Fracture
Probability in Men and Women from the UK. Osteoporosis International, 19, 385-397.
Kanis, J., Oden, A., Johnell, O., Johansson, H., De Laet, C., Brown, J., Burckhardt, P., Cooper, C., Christiansen, C., Cummings, S., Eisman, J., Fujiwara, S., Glüer, C., Goltzman, D., Hans, D., Krieg, M., La Croix, A., McCloskey, E., Mellstrom, D., Melton, L., Pols,. H., Reeve, J., Sanders, K., Schott, A., Silman, A., Torgerson, D., van Staa, T., Watts, N., & Yoshimura, N. (2007). The Use of Clinical Risk Factors Enhances the Performance of BMD in the Prediction of Hip and Osteoporotic Fractures in Men and Women. Osteoporosis International, 18 (8), 1033-1046.
Karagas, M.R., Lu-Yao, G.L., Barrett, J.A., Beach, M.L., & Baron, J.A. (1996). Heterogeneity of Hip Fracture: Age, Race, Sex, and Geographic Patterns of Femoral Neck and Trochanteric Fractures among the US Elderly. American Journal of Epidemiology, 7 (143), 677-682.
Klinge, I. (2010). Innovative Changes in Biomedicine: Integration of Sex and Gender Aspects in Research and Clinical Practice. GenderChange in Academia, 10, 231-242.
LeBlanc, E.S., Nielson, C.M., Marshall, L.M., Lapidus, J.A., Barrett-Connor, E., Ensrud, K.E., Hoffman, A.R., Laughlin, G., Ohlsson, C., & Orwoll, E.S. (2009). The Effects of Serum Testosterone, Estradiol, and Sex Hormone Binding Globulin Levels on Fracture Risk in Older Men. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, 94, 3337-3346.
Lei, S.F., Deng, F.Y., Liu, X.H., Huang, Q.R., Qin, Y., Zhou, Q., Jiang, D.K., Li, Y.M., Mo, X.Y., Liu, M.Y., Chen, X.D., Wu, X.S., Shen, H., Dvornyk, V., Zhao, L., Recker, R.R., & Deng, H.W. (2003). Polymorphisms of Four Bone Mineral Density Candidate Genes in Chinese Populations and Comparison with Other Populations of Different Ethnicity. Journal of Bone and Mineral Metabolism, 21, 34-42.
Looker, A.C., Orwoll, E.S., Johnston, C.C. Jr., Lindsay, R.L., Wahner, H.W., Dunn, W.L., Calvo, M.S., Harris, T.B., & Heyse, S.P. (1997). Prevalence of Low Femoral Bone Density in Older U.S. Adults from NHANES III. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 11 (12), 1761-8.
Meier, C., Nguyen, T.V., Handelsman, D.J., Schindler, C., Kushnir, M.M., Rockwood, A.L., Meikle, A.W., Center, J.R., Eisman, J.A., & Seibel, M.J. (2008). Endogenous Sex Hormones and Incident Fracture Risk in Older Men. Archives of Internal Medicine, 168, 47-54.
Mellström, D., Vandenput, L., Mallmin, H., Holmberg, A.H., Lorentzon, M., Odén, A., Johansson, H., Orwoll, E.S., Labrie, F., Karlsson, M.K., Ljunggren, O., & Ohlsson, C. (2008). Older Men with Low Serum Estradiol and High Serum SHBG Have an Increased Risk of Fractures. Journal of Bone Mineral Research, 23, 1552-1560.
Melton, L.J. 3rd, Marquez, M.A., Achenbach, S.J., Tefferi, A., O’Connor, M.K., O’Fallon, W.M., & Riggs, B.L. (2002). Variations in Bone Density Among Persons of African Heritage. Osteoporosis International, 7 (13), 551-559.
Melton, L.J. 3rd. (2001). The Prevalence of Osteoporosis: Gender and Racial Comparison. Calcified Tissue International, 69 (4), 179-81.
Melton, L.J. 3rd, Khosla, S., Achenbach, S.J., O’Connor, M.K., O’Fallon, W.M., & Riggs, B.L. (2000). Effects of Body Size and Skeletal Site on the Estimated Prevalence of Osteoporosis in Women and Men. Osteoporosis International, 11 (11), 977-983.
Miller, P.D. (2006). Guidelines for the Diagnosis of Osteoporosis: T-scores vs Fractures. Reviews in Endocrine & Metabolic Disorders, 7, 75-89.
Orwoll, E.S. (2009). Abstract—Grant Number: 5U01AG027810-03, Project Title: Osteporotic [sic] Fractures in Men (MrOS)-Admin Center. Computer Retrieval of Information on Scientific Projects (CRISP). National Institutes of Health. Retrieved 28 February 2009 from
Orwoll, E., Blank, J.B., Barrett-Connor, E., Cauley, J., Cummings, S., Ensrud, K., Lewis, C., Cawthon, P.M., Marcus, R., Marshall, L.M., McGowan, J., Phipps, K., Sherman, S., Stefanick, M.L., & Stone, K. (2005). Design and Baseline Characteristics of the Osteoporotic Fractures in Men (MrOS) Study—A Large Observational Study of the Determinants of Fracture in Older Men. Contemporary Clinical Trials, 26, 569-585.
Qaseem, A., Snow, V., Shekelle, P., Hopkins, R. Jr., Forciea, M.A., & Owens, D.K. (2008). Screening for Osteoporosis in Men: A Clinical Practice Guideline from the American College of Physicians. Annals of Internal Medicine, 9 (148), 680-684.
Sweet, M.G., Sweet, J.M., Jeremiah, M.P., & Galazka, S.S. (2009). Diagnosis and Treatment of Osteoporosis. American Family Physician, 3 (79), 193-200.
Szulc, P., Kaufman, J., & Orwoll, E. (2012). Osteoporosis in Men. Journal of Osteoporosis, 1-5.
Whitaker, M., Guo, J., Kehoe, T., & Benson, G. (2012). Bisphosphonates for Osteoporosis--Where Do We Go from Here? New England Journal of Medicine, online in advance of print.
Wong, S.Y.S., Lau, E.M.C., Lynn, H., Leung, P.C., Woo, J., Cummings, S.R., & Orwoll, E. (2004). Depression and Bone Mineral Density: Is There A Relationship in Elderly Asian Men? Results From Mr. OS (Hong Kong). Osteoporosis International, 6 (16), 610-615.
Wiemann, L.M., Vallarta-Ast, N., Krueger, D., & Binkley, N. (2007). Effect of Female Database Use for T-score Derivation in Men. Journal of Clinical Densitometry, 2 (9), 238.
The World Health Organization. (2003). Prevention and Management of Osteoporosis: Report of a WHO Scientific Group. Geneva, Switzerland.
Wu, X.P., et al. (2003). A Comparison Study of the Reference Curves of Bone Mineral Density at Different Skeletal Sites in Native Chinese, Japanese, and American Caucasian Women. Calcified Tissue International, 73, 122-132.